1. A creamy, neutral eyeliner. Depending on your hair and eye color, as well as your skin tone and personal preference, this could be a pale taupe, a deep brown, a medium gray, or a deep, dark black. Keep some cotton swabs on hand to smudge the line you draw, buffing it out ever so slightly.
2. A sheer gloss. I lied: Having a fourth lip product that feels good and has a bit of a moist look is always a good idea. This can be layered over any of the above, or worn alone when you’re feeling glossy. (Try Burt’s Bees Lip Shimmer in Peony topped with a light coating of Burt’s Bees Lip Gloss in Ocean Sunrise.)
3. A mascara that gives the look you favor, whether that’s longer, thicker, darker, or all of the above. I prefer all of the above.